While I love the idea of an entire issue dedicated to "shapely" aka "normal" women,
Vogue takes an interesting tone in each article interviewing women of "size" this year.
Instead of simply highlighting Mindy Kaling's ridiculous achievements, things that she did despite *gasp* being 5 pounds overweight, they talk to her about: what it's like to be slightly overweight. To me, it doesn't sound like Kaling really has a problem with her weight, and although she claims she is always trying to lose 5 (aren't we all?), life is pretty awesome and she is generally killing it.
Whoa. Newsflash! Life can be great even if you aren't a model!
Next we have an interview with Annie Thorisdottir, the strongest female in the world, according to her success in the Cross Fit Championships. Nothing is said about her being overweight, because she has layers of 6-packs. She buys Louboutins to reward herself for winning the world championship Cross Fit Games. Sweet. She's okay.
Next is... a pregnant actress? Emily Blunt is normally a thin, hugely busy actress, but, maybe because there aren't any other shapely, yet successful, women other than Mindy and Annie Thorisdottir, Vogue went out and found a pregnant lady, who will only be shapely for... 4 months? And we follow her around as she shops for maternity clothes. Because, let's be honest, there is nothing related to a shape issue to speak of in this story. Maybe I'm mistaken and this was just a misplaced article.
My very favorite is the
article on Kimye.
We all know that
Vogue editor-in-chief Anna Wintor
hates Kim. I couldn't wait for this issue with Kimye on the cover to come out so I could read the Letter from the Editor. Wintor has a smug "we did this on purpose and of our own accord" tone regarding the Kim Kardashian photo shoot and article.
Flipping to the article, I soon saw why. Not only does she get to be the cover of the shape issue (which she doesn't mind, I'm sure),
Vogue doesn't have to do much to make Kim look ridiculous. In fact, I think the writer actually tried to paint her in a fairytale manner.
But, at some point you have to include quotes in an article. And when Kim talks, well, she sounds like an idiot. Pretty much unavoidable. It's a highly entertaining read, because sometimes, when you watch
Keeping Up with the Kardashians, their butts get in the way of what they are saying and you don't quite relish the fact that, they are ridiculous.
Wintor 1, Kardashian clan 0. Again.
Of course we have an article on Kate Upton... blah blah blah, so boring I didn't finish it.
This begs the larger question: why do we read Vogue? Or any fashion magazine in the first place? We do it to have something to strive for. I, for one, am fully aware that every model has not only gone through hours of hair and make up to look tousled on the beach, but in addition, Photoshop is an amazing tool. But, there is something to attain (aka fake perfection?).
We read it for the glitz and glam. I know living in the middle of nowhere, I sure do.
When Vogue puts out their yearly shape issue, we read it, feel inspired to be who we are and feel comfortable in our own clothes and chubby thighs. But, when the tone of the issue is focusing on living in a size 10 instead of LIVING, I just want to hide under a bush (and I'm not even a size 10).
Thoughts?